The New Times – Latest News Page

A Modern Architect of the Western

Taylor Sheridan has become one of the most influential voices in modern television and cinema. Known for creating the Yellowstone franchise and producing titles like Landman, Sheridan also established himself in film with acclaimed screenplays for Sicario and Hell or High Water. His signature style blends contemporary grit with classic Western themes, appealing to mainstream audiences while provoking debate among critics.

Yet Sheridan’s body of work has never been uniformly praised. His projects often swing between critical acclaim and polarizing reception, with quality sometimes varying even within the same series. As his universe expands, fans and reviewers alike continue to weigh which works stand as masterpieces and which fall short.

Sheridan’s Missteps: Sicario: Day of the Soldado and Lawmen: Bass Reeves

Few would call Sicario: Day of the Soldado a failure. The 2018 sequel has strong performances and Sheridan’s unmistakable neo-Western flair. Still, it inevitably suffered from comparisons to Denis Villeneuve’s masterful original. Its 62% Rotten Tomatoes score reflects that while solid, the film lacked the artistic punch of Sicario. A third installment could yet restore the franchise’s reputation.

Meanwhile, Lawmen: Bass Reeves highlights the Sheridan brand without being fully his own. Though he served as executive producer, the series was led by Chad Feehan and technically sits outside the Yellowstone timeline. Despite its compelling source material and historical lens, critics noted it lacked the heart and epic scope of Sheridan’s direct creations, making it more a solid weekend binge than a franchise cornerstone.

The Rising Potential of Landman

Sheridan’s Landman became an instant hit on Paramount+ with Billy Bob Thornton leading the cast. The show’s first season was widely watched, though not without flaws. Episodes often faltered when Thornton wasn’t on screen, revealing narrative gaps. The upcoming second season, bolstered by Demi Moore, Sam Elliott, and Andy Garcia, offers a chance to deepen the story and prove the show’s long-term viability. If it succeeds, Landman could emerge as one of Sheridan’s defining works.

Cinematic Strength: Wind River and Hell or High Water

Sheridan’s 2017 film Wind River stands as one of his most understated triumphs. Starring Jeremy Renner, Elizabeth Olsen, and Gil Birmingham, the film blends neo-Western atmosphere with murder mystery tension. Its stark Wyoming setting becomes a character in itself, underscoring Sheridan’s gift for landscape-driven storytelling.

Equally acclaimed, Hell or High Water cemented Sheridan as a writer capable of delivering both authenticity and urgency. With a 97% Rotten Tomatoes score, the 2016 film remains one of the most highly praised neo-Westerns of the century. Its combination of sharp dialogue, grounded action, and thematic resonance makes it a benchmark in Sheridan’s career.

Yellowstone: Success and Controversy

No Sheridan project has loomed larger than Yellowstone. The series, headlined by Kevin Costner, redefined cable television, blending prestige elements with soapy, addictive drama. For many fans, seasons two and three marked the show’s creative peak. Later seasons, however, drew criticism for melodrama, behind-the-scenes conflict, and Costner’s abrupt departure.

The decision to kill off John Dutton off-screen after a long hiatus remains one of the show’s most divisive choices. Still, Yellowstone built an empire, spawning multiple spinoffs and making Sheridan the most powerful name in Western television.

The Ambition of 1883 and 1923

If Yellowstone was Sheridan’s empire builder, 1883 was his boldest experiment. With sweeping ambition and a near-unanimous critical reception, the prequel captured the Dutton family’s roots with frontier grandeur. Its 89% Rotten Tomatoes score reflects both its ambition and execution, appealing to classic Western enthusiasts.

Then came 1923, often hailed as Sheridan’s best television work to date. With Harrison Ford and Helen Mirren anchoring the cast, the series elevated itself with nuanced writing and powerful performances. Its 94% critical score and awards recognition further cemented its status as one of Sheridan’s crown jewels.

Sicario: Where It All Began

Sheridan’s screenwriting debut, Sicario, remains his most important milestone. Directed by Denis Villeneuve, the 2015 thriller married Western tropes with modern cartel warfare. The result was a gripping, morally complex film hailed by both critics and audiences. With a 92% Rotten Tomatoes score and a place in contemporary film canon, Sicario is often regarded as Sheridan’s purest work.

A Legacy Still Unfolding

Taylor Sheridan’s career is marked by extremes: bold experiments, commercial triumphs, and creative misfires. What unites them all is a distinct voice — one that elevates rugged landscapes, flawed characters, and timeless themes of survival and power. Whether in the courtroom battles of Yellowstone, the frontier tragedy of 1883, or the tense corridors of Sicario, Sheridan has kept the Western alive by reshaping it for modern audiences.

As new projects like Landman evolve and Yellowstone’s spinoffs take shape, Sheridan’s legacy is still being written. And while his work will always spark debate, his influence on the Western genre is undeniable, ensuring that his name remains synonymous with the frontier he so vividly brings to life.